Wagoner County Commissioners are defending their decision made in June of 2025 to deny a conditional use permit to Persica Solar, LLC for the construction of a 5,000 acre solar farm near the city of Porter. The solar farm developer also defends its project.
Responding to a June filing in Wagoner County District court where Persica, a subsidiary of NextEra Energy filed suit last year, the county commission stated, “The BOCC denied Persica’s application because Persica did not prove that its proposed industrial-scale solar facility would be for the benefit of the surrounding area, and none of Persica’s grounds warrant setting that decision aside.”
Attorneys for the commissioners further argued the court should affirm the determinations by the County Commission and the County Planning Commission that “the project does not benefit the surrounding communnity.” They also contended that solar energy farms are considered to be “conditional” uses in the county’s agricultural district and it was up to Persica to prove the $336 million project would benefit the surrouding area.
The commissioners further asserted that Persica treats the conditional permit as an entitlement even though the Zoning code places the burden on the applicant to prove th proposed use satisfies the governing standard.
“The applicant does not prevail by default,” said the filing, adding that the Court must decide whether Persica proved the project benefits the surrounding community.
In the June court filing, Persica contended it met the conditions for the permit, ““Persica has unquestionably satisfied the requirements for a conditional use permit to construct a solar energy farm on agricultural property in Wagoner County and the only question before this Court would be “whether the board of adjustment was possessed of discretionary authority to create additional conditions, and if imposed, whether they were reasonable,” argued attorney Jim Roth in the June 16 filing.
Days after County Commissioners filed their response this month, landowner Brian Livesay, who agreed to sell his land for the site of the prospective solar farm, filed a letter to the District Judge hearing the lawsuit, urging the judge to support Persica Solar.
“I respectfully ask the Court to consider the reasons given by the commissioners that voted to deny the conditional use permit at the time of the denial: a belief that what the zoning code clearly states is incorrect, and an in-the-moment gut feeling. The ability of property owners to benefit the county, local schools, and themselves should not be denied by a commissioner’s desire for the code to be different than it is, nor by what gives a commissionera better feeling in their gut at that moment.”
Livesay referred to one County Commissioner who said he “had to go with his gut” in voting against the project.
In recent days, Persica Solar answered the county commissioners by stating that it did make the case for the project and county commissioners in 2022 amended the Zoning Ordinance to allow private solar or wind energy farms on agricultural property upon issuance of a conditional use permit. The decision was made after the commissioners learned a private solar facility was interested in operating in Wagoner County.
Persica contended in the July 24 filing that the company “easily satisfied” the burden of demonstrating the Project’s “benefit of the surrounding area.”
