Opens in a new tab

Looking for more news? Visit our sister site, OK Politics Today, and subscribe here today!

Supreme Court
October 6, 2026

Supreme Court hears climate change lawsuit against oil and gas

U.S. Supreme Court Justices reacted Monday almost sympathetically toward the oil and gas industry as it fends off a climate change lawsuit filed by Boulder, Colorado.

Different media had the same opinion of the reaction of the justices following the two-hour hearing. The city of Boulder and the Boulder County Commission filed suit in 2018 against Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy, blaming the oil firms for climate change which led to a deadly monster wildfire that destroyed more than a thousand homes in 2021. Suncor and Exxon appealed and their case was the first to be heard in the new term of the Supreme Court.

Justices were told in opening arguments by Suncor attorney Kannon K. Shanmugam, “If Boulder’s claims are allowed to go forward, some 90,000 municipalities across the country will have the ability to make national and international energy policy by asking juries to impose catastrophic damages on selected fossil-fuel producers.”

Colorado Newsline’s opening line described it this way, “The U.S. Supreme Court’s conservative majority Monday appeared broadly sympathetic to fossil fuel companies’ argument that allowing two Colorado local governments to sue them over climate change in state court would be a “recipe for chaos.”

As justices waded into a thicket of jurisdictional issues raised by Suncor and Exxon when they petitioned the nation’s highest court to weigh in last year, Chief Justice John Roberts noted the “practical matter” of what could happen nationwide if Boulder’s case is allowed to proceed, continued Newsline.

“Presumably if you prevail, the next day, a municipality in every single state will file a lawsuit, probably copy your pleadings, and then there’ll be at least 50 … causes of action filed,” he told the attorney representing Boulder. “How would you think that will work out on the ground?”

NBC News had much the same description—that the justices displayed some sympathy from the bench toward the oil companies.

Chief Justice John Roberts, one of the court’s conservatives, wondered how many more cities and counties would launch similar lawsuits if the court allows the Boulder case to continue.

“Just to make sure I have a correct understanding. Presumably, if you prevail, the next day a municipality in every single state will file a lawsuit,” he told Boulder’s lawyer, Kevin Russell.

Roberts also seemed skeptical that the lawsuit was anything other than what he called “an effort to reduce emissions,” reported NBC.

Other justices also seemed conflicted. Liberal Justice Elena Kagan at one point compared climate litigation with the wave of lawsuits against tobacco companies and drug manufacturers that sold opioids, which were allowed to proceed.

The most vocal justice in backing the oil companies was conservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who cited several court precedents that he said were “crystal clear” that air and water pollution are matters of federal law that the states cannot regulate.

“We don’t have to reinvent the wheel because we’ve said this multiple times,” he added.

Share this article:

About the Author